6 Cozy Cookie Recipes to Bake This Fall

Fall is the season of warm spices, golden leaves, and cozy afternoons spent baking. There is nothing better than filling your kitchen with the comforting aroma of cinnamon, nutmeg, and browned butter while pulling out a tray of freshly baked cookies. If you are searching for the best fall cookie recipes, these six are a perfect mix of pumpkin, chai, caramel, banana bread, and even peach cobbler. Classic fall flavors with a creative twist.

1. Pumpkin Oatmeal Cream Pies

These soft pumpkin oatmeal cookies sandwich a sweet cream filling for the ultimate fall dessert. A cozy upgrade to the nostalgic oatmeal cream pie, they are perfect for bake sales, lunchbox treats, or Thanksgiving dessert platters.

2. Brown Butter Banana Bread Cookies

Chewy, golden, and packed with ripe banana flavor, these cookies bring banana bread into cookie form. The browned butter adds a nutty depth, making these a must bake for any fall cookie tray.

3. Dirty Chai Latte Cookies

Coffee lovers this one is for you. These cookies combine bold espresso with warming chai spices for the ultimate afternoon pick me up. They taste like your favorite cafe drink turned into a cookie.

4. Pumpkin Roll Cookies

Inspired by the classic pumpkin roll cake, these cookies swirl pumpkin spice dough with a cream cheese filling. They are as beautiful as they are delicious and always impress at fall gatherings.

5. Brown Butter Chai Caramel Marble Cookies

These cookies are giving cozy coffee shop meets moody autumn walk. They swirl warm chai spices and brown butter with a caramel ribbon and a spiced sugar crust. You will want a blanket and a second batch.

6. Peach Cobbler Cookies

Okay yes, peach is a late summer fruit, but these cookies carry beautifully into early fall. Think golden cookie base, brown sugar crumb topping, and jammy peach pockets. Only available in my digital cookbook Cookies from Classics.

Save These Fall Cookies for Later

Whether you are craving pumpkin spice, caramel swirl, or a coffee infused treat, these cozy fall cookies will make your kitchen smell incredible and your cookie jar impossible to keep full. Bake one or bake them all and you will have a sweet taste of autumn in every bite.

Keywords: fall cookie recipes, pumpkin cookies, chai cookies, cozy cookies for fall, best cookies for autumn baking

Thanks for spending a little bit of your fall era with me in the kitchen. Whether you're baking your way through the season or just here for the cozy vibes, I’m so glad you’re part of this community.

Until the next batch,

Samantha
Founder, recipe developer, and unapologetic brown butter enthusiast